Rules and Rebellion

By

Mojgan Rah

Two

“Anna! You can’t just leave like this!” I stopped her.

“Why not?” She yanked her hand free. “You have all decided it’s on me, what happened then… and now.”

She looked at me. Not defiant, not sharp—helpless, broken. The way I’d never seen her, the way she never let anyone see. For a moment, it almost worked.

“You say it’s not? Then defend yourself!” I said.

“Would you believe me?” Her eyes stayed on mine. “Do you really think I made her hurt people? That I pushed her until she killed herself? Well… maybe I could, but why?” She looked away. “You know I would never—”

I wanted to believe her. And that was exactly the problem.

“For fun,” I snapped. “You do that a lot. Just for fun.”

“John… I would never hurt anyone…” Her voice cracked. “I thought you knew that.”

She sounded sincere. That was exactly how she always fooled people.

“No, Anna. I don’t know. You do things that make it impossible to trust you,” I said, wishing I could just take her word for it.

“I wasn’t even there, I just…” She paused, frustrated. “Whatever. There’s nothing I can do to make you believe me.”

“For God’s sake, Anna. You just said you could do that,” I replied, louder than I wanted.

“So what?” she shot back. “Be real, John. This world isn’t a fairy tale. Anyone can, even you.”

“No!” The word came out too fast. “Only a psycho like you thinks that way.”

The moment it left my mouth, I knew I had crossed a line. I shouldn’t have said that.

She looked at me as if she couldn’t believe me. “Only unrealistic bastards like you think otherwise.”

She turned to leave. She always knew how to do that. Leave the mess behind and walk away.

“Leaving again, huh?” I yelled. “Like always. Causing trouble and running away. Typical you.”

Without looking back, she said, “You’re right. It’s my fault. I’m the trouble. No me, no trouble!”

Then she walked away. I stood there watching her leave. Strangely, my chest ached.

“Hey, John,” my colleague called out. “Did you just let her go?”

“Yeah. It’s better that way. She’s no help,” I replied.

“But what if—”

“She’s not the murderer,” I snapped.

“How do you know?” he asked. “Have you forgotten how she is?”

“No, that’s exactly why,” I said, my voice faltering. “She would never hurt anyone.”

“Yeah? Bet she would.”

I looked away. I had no defense.

We headed back to the station in silence, with zero progress.

Even now, with everything stacked against her, I was still looking for reasons to doubt the evidence. I had sworn I would never choose her over the truth again. And yet, here I am.

I couldn’t help but think about the old days—about our last case. I pulled out the old dusty file, and I let the old memories return.

***

The police academy was as busy as ever, everyone minding their own business—except her. She was… minding everyone else’s business.

She walked straight toward me as if she’d caught me watching her.

“Hello, handsome,” she said, smiling. “It’s Anna.”

“John,” I muttered, blushing.

“Good. We’re teammates now,” she said, winking.

That was Anna: she argued with instructors and asked questions no one else dared to ask. She wasn’t lawless; she just used it as she pleased. And I used to admire her. But not for long…

By our final year, theory had turned into real cases. Real streets. Real consequences. That’s when everything changed.

A man had been stalking a girl for weeks. Messages. Following her home. But nothing that would stick.

“That’s dangerous,” I said.

“We need evidence,” Anna snapped. “He’s careful. He knows the system.” She paced the room. “He won’t touch her again unless he thinks she’s alone.”

“We won’t use her as bait,” I insisted.

“Oh, right. We wait until she becomes a real prey,” she shot back. “Sorry. My bad, I keep forgetting these stupid rules.”

“No, we’re not, ugh!” I knew I was right, but she had a point. “I’m just saying, don’t do anything stupid.”

“But—”

“No buts, Anna. We’re not doing it,” I said, leaving no room for argument. “Please. I’m tired of cleaning up your mess every time. If you do anything, I swear I’ll report it this time.”

“Fine, I won’t do anything,” she said, resigned. “But I hope you don’t have to clean your own mess. At her funeral, that is.”

Things were quiet after that. She wasn’t around that much. I was wondering if she had actually listened to me. Then came the day, the victim called asking for help. We rushed there.

By the time we arrived, Anna was already there. The man was on the ground—cuffed, bleeding. He glared at Anna as they dragged him to the car. The girl had a wound on her arm. Blood stained her clothes.

Officers questioned her carefully:

“So he followed you?”

“Yes.”

“And Officer Blake intervened?”

“Yeah, she was nearby.”

“Miss, are you hurt any—”

“No,” she said quickly, covering her wound. “It’s just a scratch.”

She seemed nervous. And that was enough for me to see the truth. Their lie settled easily—too easily.

Anna was nearby, tired but proud. She approached the girl, brushing dirt from her sleeves and giving her hand a warm squeeze.

“It’s over now,” she said.

I had never resented her more. How could she act so gently after nearly getting her killed?

The girl should have been scared, maybe even angry. And yet she looked at Anna with gratitude like someone who had been saved, not endangered. She was hiding the truth, only to protect her. I couldn’t understand it—that loyalty, that devotion. Anna would always find someone to shield her.

I walked toward her. Furiously grabbed her arm and pulled her close.

“I warned you, this is the last time,” I whispered.

She flinched. “Easy, man. Don’t worry, it is the last time,” she winked.

Something felt off about her. I didn’t care. I wanted her to hurt—maybe only then she’d learn.

I had the report ready that night. Clear. Accurate. Unforgiving. But Anna showed up.

“Oh, someone’s too serious,” she joked.

“Not in the mood,” I said, not even looking at her.

“Look, John,” she said, her voice softer—pleading, not like her. “We have him now. Don’t ruin everything.”

“Oh, so I am the one ruining everything!” I snapped. “She was bleeding, Anna, don’t you see how wrong it could’ve gone?”

“Just this one last time. Please!” she begged. “If you report it, they might free him. You know what he’s like.”

She had a point, but I still couldn’t forgive what she’d done.

“I promise,” she continued. “I’ll leave. Isn’t that what you want?”

My heart sank. I didn’t know why. It should’ve been great news. She was never made for this job. Just one lie and she would be gone, but… it felt wrong.

I looked at her, unbelieving. “Why would you—”

“It’s not even that fun anymore.” She smiled. “Plus, being stuck with all these stupid rules is not really my thing.”

“Guess I have to choose between worst and worse,” I said cruelly.

“I knew I could count on you,” she said, joking one last time. “Goodbye, handsome.”

***

Now, years later, I watched her disappear again.

I played the footage—the evidence she risked everything for. The attacker moved fast. The victim stumbled back, falling out of frame. I paused the video and leaned closer to the screen. Something felt different about her. I played it again. Then again.

The camera caught her face for half a second. Blurred but familiar. I scrolled forward. The attacker lunged. Something sharp flashed. Blood.

I checked the report. The girl had said it was “just a scratch,” barely worth mentioning. I remembered Anna that night: her weary face, the flinch of pain.

“No me, no trouble!” Her last words played in my mind.

Ding!

I was jolted by the notification: a message from Anna.