Shades of Beholding

By

Marnix Sixma

I followed the woman inside, along with the others who had come to the viewing. She couldn’t have been that much older than me, but her clothes suggested money, expertise and elegance, real estate’s holy trinity. After showing two gloomy studios next to the main entrance, she led us into the first garden apartment, 1-4A. A lone pillar stood in the center of the space, as if welcoming us. The woman’s ivory blonde hair danced against the sterile glow of fresh white paint while she answered questions. I’d rarely seen such an open space. Everything breathed daylight. I drifted from the conversation to look out one of the windows that surrounded the apartment. A street stretched on toward a vanishing point of traffic lights, turning green as if approving.

Change was still well beyond the horizon. The future held its breath.

SCARLET

I moved into apartment 1-4A on a mild, damp day in August. Summer was on its way out, but it was still warm. When I biked home at night with friends, I could point out my place from far away. Look, there, right beneath those bright red neon letters. Below ‘Utopia’.

The place used to be a nursing home. Already in my first week, I noticed neighbors passing by my windows at all hours, circling the inner courtyard to reach their front doors. Each time created small, indeterminate moments of decision: do I wave or not? Do I look out or pretend I’m busy? Maybe a nod, a silent hey there neighbor, how are you?

At times it was amusing to exchange a glance with someone, but it also was a strange setup. In hindsight it reminded me of sidewalk cafés: everything outside the terrace is a scenery for the drinker, while the drinker becomes a backdrop for the passerby. As more chairs fill up, however, everyone inside the terrace becomes part of a shared tableau; a crowd made up exclusively of anonymous spirits.

Maybe it had something to do with a perceived difference in density: the more people there are, the greater the sense of anonymity. And the greater the anonymity, the easier it becomes to look.

The housing association had pitched Utopia as a home for young professionals, but it quickly became clear they hadn’t meant that too literally. Bit by bit, it turned into a popular spot for students and richer freshmen. As soon as the weather turned pleasant, picnic tables were garnished with oversized wicker umbrellas and strings of colored lights. It wasn’t just neighbors sneaking the occasional glance through my windows anymore. Everyone using the garden seemed to feel entitled to look in. I didn’t have words yet for the vague feeling creeping in. I tucked it in tenderly, still too awake to fall asleep.

At the time, I was seeing a girl called Sam. Plants bathed in the red of looming neon when she came over for the first time. Beneath the grass, the seeds of everything still hidden were beginning to stir, thoughts slowly thawing in their wintery coats. Spring would come; harvest could wait.

More than once that night, footsteps echoed along the brick perimeter of the garden. Like a distant thunder, drawing closer, swelling into a first glimpse of a figure. Even after they disappeared from view, their presence lingered. I could almost identify my neighbors by the pace of their footsteps, one quick and cheerful, another slow and imposing. I think it was the latter who passed by just then.

As Sam tracked the heavy thuds outside the windows, her eyes first widened and then narrowed. “Don’t you feel constantly like you’re being watched here?” she asked as she sat upright, staring at the last window the neighbor had just passed. My apartment must have roused not only her curiosity, but also some kind of heightened alert; the mix of hesitation and conclusion in her voice confirmed how I’d been reading her body language.

It was like her words reached in and pulled me back to the present, though my eyes were still clouded with sleep. A realization started to crack from just beneath my skin, as if to articulate itself in hindsight, through nerve endings I hadn’t even known were there. The first jolt feels alien. After that, the world takes on a different hue, a new clarity.

“They’re just my neighbors,” I said with a shrug, but I think we both saw right through that clumsy attempt at reassurance. “Would you like me to close the curtains?” I asked, even though I wouldn’t have dared to under different circumstances. But I was glad I did; once the room was fully ours again, she seemed to relax. Her gaze, no longer able to reach the glass, turned back to what was unfolding inside. The thunder passed by; a barking dog, no longer able to engage with us.

***

That night, I’d managed to resolve the discomfort, but I realized a more structural solution was needed. That same week, I covered a good half of my windows with matte film, leaving a narrow strip open at the top and bottom. The sitting area with the TV still looked out onto the garden; I wanted to keep my view on the blackbirds hunting for worms in the morning light.

The film only made things worse. Without meaning to, I had framed the passerby’s gaze. The diorama that was my home became less accessible, and therefore more exclusive, more intriguing, more titillating. The very part that still allowed a view seemed to beg for the light to enter without obstruction. With that light, gazes spilled into my life.

Light has no substance. Yet it had found its way inside my home. What had once drifted in as scattered spores on the wind began to attach, to settle, to grow. It started to fill the air and saturate the room temperature I breathed. Axons fired, faster and faster, footpaths widening into two-lane roads. What had once appeared as a seemingly random form began to wear a groove. But like a game show where the letters have to be guessed, I could only speculate at the words being spelled.

My neighbors hadn’t felt like such a problem to me: we were mostly lone wanderers, absorbed in our own daily reflections. The gradient between us was zero, none of us was anonymous, and with that, a kind of mutual respect remained intact. But crowds derive their anonymity from a density gradient with their surroundings.

Soon after, small party congregations began to indulge in the tropically adorned summer garden. When I was watching a show with some dinner on my lap, I’d find myself gawked at by people sitting just a few meters away. It drove me nuts. My apartment felt like an analog channel, my life free-to-stream content: ad-free and available to all. I wanted to do as I pleased, how I pleased and with whom I pleased. And, last but not least, I wanted to watch whatever I pleased.

If a spicy scene came on, I felt like a pervert. If I watched a Japanese anime, I felt like a nerd. The stuffed animals my girlfriend had given me to keep me company—I liked to prop them up on the armrest of the couch so they could look outside. But ‘outside’ had become an ambiguous concept, its meaning swinging like a pendulum; a circadian rhythm with wildly fluctuating perceived temperatures.

Only at night, when half-closed flowers and quietly swaying shrubs offered no gaze in return, did the window feel like it was truly mine.

My home had become an extension of the outside world: the gaze of the other was always inside, had hung its coat next to mine. The feeling that I was never truly alone stayed with me. With the curtains open, I didn’t feel like myself, but like whoever I seemed to be to the person on the far side of the portal.

I molted slowly, turned inside out.

My skin became glass.

LILAC

Six years after moving into Utopia, I got the chance to take over an apartment from two friends, right in the heart of the city. It was much larger, on the third floor, and had significantly fewer windows.

The house across the street was uninhabited. Thin horizontal strips of closed blinds hung undisturbed behind the windows; the upper panes were always cracked open. Over the years, wisteria had overtaken the rickety rooftop terrace. Even the hatch leading to the roof seemed to have surrendered long ago.

The building appeared so permanently abandoned that friends started making up ghost stories about it. The windows were never opened any wider; the blinds never moved. Only the bluish-purple blossoms kept expanding. Amid the surrounding rooftops, the house sat static and unmoving. In a landscape of wood, stone, and curling smoke, the flowers seemed the only living beings remaining.

Change always plans its own arrival.

A little over six months later, the wisteria disappeared overnight. Two men stood on the uneven, warping planks, silently surveying the scene. Loose petals and shredded bits of flower were scattered around them. Their eyes moved across the wood, the asymmetrical stonework, the thin wire strung along the edges—seemingly without purpose. They exchanged a word or two. From the pristine state of their clothing, it was clear the wisteria hadn’t put up a fight.

The sight of those two men was enough for my body to brace itself. The memories of the recent past were still fresh, a thin pearlescent layer over the express lanes of my central nervous system. Even the subtlest signals were welcomed and escorted to their destination. My body and I already thought we knew what was coming.

Only we didn’t—not yet, not really. Assumption after assumption, time corrected us gently and patiently: it’s okay, look again. Your eyes just need some time.

***

Curly red hair, pale skin. Freckled, though it was hard to tell from a distance.

Suddenly, my view was anything but lifeless. During the day, the blinds were almost always open. For the first time, I could see the room that had been hidden for all those years. Her bed stood by the left-hand window, a nightstand behind it with a lamp, clippings and postcards pinned to the wall. When I try to recall the window to the right, I find I no longer know which memories are from then, and which from now. What I do remember is the orange glow of the small microwave on her floor, which she used to warm a cherry stone pillow before going to sleep.

I felt self-conscious.

Once or twice, we made eye contact while we were both at home, too brief and awkward to pass for a silent hello. One day, there were streamers hanging in her room. I almost grabbed a sheet of paper and scrawled HAPPY BIRTHDAY on it, capital letters with a smiley underneath, but it felt like crossing a line.

She started dating. Did she realize how little the shadows on the closed roller blind left to the imagination? It felt like seeing something not meant for me, something visible only because of our geographic positions and the way the light happened to fall in her apartment. When she walked past the right-hand window in her underwear before going to sleep, I wondered whether she simply didn’t notice that the blind was open. Or did she know I could see her, but didn’t mind? There was a kind of warmth in that openness, as if we shared a house, the street between us no more than a hallway.

I’d grown used to being visible in my previous home, but now that visibility was mirrored. Did the principle of density still hold? Were we still lone wanderers, or had we become something unprecedented?

It wasn’t until much later that I realized I was wondering how she experienced the space we shared. Whether she, in the midst of our seemingly always averted gazes, ever thought about my life. About how I meditated each morning, seated, back straight, eyes closed. How I ate my dinner on the little couch in the bay window, my gaze fixed northward, toward the crowds on the market square at the end of the street. What, if anything, did I mean to her?

Back then, I kept a sort of diary for myself using the voice recorder on my phone. She might have thought I talked to myself, as I sometimes recorded voice-memos late at night, in pitch darkness. I loved the night, the shadows that filled my apartment. I could look out onto the street unnoticed, a silhouette, a presence reduced to a gaze. A gaze that couldn’t be seen.

But once you’re neighbors, you can try all you want. You’re never truly alone.

If she was watching, I wonder how often. Often enough to notice something? Time didn’t speak in chapters; it simply walked on, blind to its own footprints.

***

Shortly after she moved in, I painted my nails for the first time. The city was basking in the afterglow of summer.

Crouched at my little table, I focused on painting just my pinky nails; I didn’t dare paint the others yet. ‘Nobody is looking at me,’ I repeated like a mantra in my head. ‘Everybody is doing their own thing.’ But it was no use. My thoughts kept circling to my neighbor and a friend sitting on the rooftop terrace across from me. I didn’t look, and hoped I wasn’t being looked at in return. Realism and magical thinking went hand in hand.

I can now see how much I was struggling with myself.

Those weeks—the time of the first bottles of nail polish—felt like a dot from which multiple lines began to extend, processes set in motion. Of course, that dot wasn’t a true beginning, but a continuation of something already moving, a ripple in a pond. Still, the lines began to declare themselves more clearly, and maybe that made them seem new to others: the nail polish, my hair, the way I held my body. My thoughts about myself, about the world.

At first, I kept these changes hidden from most of my friends and family. At home, I shed the whole spectrum of possible interpretations others might project onto me. When I closed the front door behind me, I became more myself.

Because of the unique geography we shared, my neighbor wasn’t really part of that outside world. In a way, she had become part of what made me feel at home. She was my first audience, besides myself in the mirror. Not just someone on the street, but her.

From the wisteria she had emerged, my first beholder.

I thought I was ready to try eyeshadow for the first time. A friend had warned me I might feel like I looked like a raccoon, and that I shouldn’t be too alarmed by that. I tried to leave the makeup on and sat down by my window. It was the height of summer. A sweltering haze hung over the city, unwilling to break into rain.

I tried simply to sit there, to let time pass, to get used to myself, but I felt so much
at once. A sharp self-consciousness, a sense of how I might appear in the eyes of others—my body, my thoughts, my feelings, they weren’t in sync. That tension must have shown on me, thick as the air outside. I knew she was home, but I didn’t dare to look her way.

The exposure I felt was different than in Utopia. My neighbor’s presence was relatively predictable, unlike that lush garden, that reservoir of shifting variables. She wasn’t there just that day, but the days before, the weeks. Month after month she had been there, perceiving me in fragments. And even though we didn’t know each other’s names, I trusted that, in some way, she understood me. That she trusted what I was doing.

It was something in her body language, her posture, her way of looking. Body language reveals someone’s openness, how much they consider you an equal. In our wordless coexistence, I began to let go, relax, even enjoy myself. In the unspoken quiet that hovered between us, we could be whoever we wanted to be.

I hoped she saw the bigger picture—that I wasn’t putting on a mask but erasing the layers that had kept me hidden until then. Somewhere in the space that opened up, a kind of trust began to take root: the fragile hope that I could be like her, be for her what she had been to me.

Once in a while I’d run into her on the street, but never did I dare to say hi. It felt like too much—who did I think I was? After all, we were just people who happened to be renting apartments in the same street. Still, I felt a kind of longing for contact, even if I didn’t know how to initiate it, what that contact could or should be. The uncertainty settled into a kind of absence I felt every day.

One day, I was walking down the street, and she happened to be cycling toward me from the other direction. I realized too late that it was her; she wore her hair differently than usual. For a moment, we made eye contact. Now I wonder if things might have turned out differently, if I had hung up that sign in my window, that one day I thought it might be her birthday. How differently our paths might have unfolded.

About a year ago, we both happened to be outside, in front of our homes. She was with her boyfriend; I was just about to leave. I can’t remember what I was wearing that day, how I looked, whether I was going through a phase where I stepped outside as my former self, or whether I had enough trust and courage to be fully me. But I do remember that we saw each other and exchanged a cautious hello. I remember her smile, that sunlit afternoon. Everything seemed to fall into place.

CHARCOAL

It has been ten years since I moved to Utopia. I think of that sunlit studio as an alchemical capsule now, a catalyst for transmutation; as if the “now” is composed of echoes from a primordial, all-defining explosion that took place there. But the truth is more elusive, more subtle. Many, if not all, of the lines I’ve come to recognize were already in motion, curling beneath the surface, whispering, proliferating. Their time—our time—simply hadn’t come yet.

It wasn’t the windows of apartment 1-4A. Nor the people in the garden, or the passersby on the street. It didn’t matter where the density was greater, the gazes were irrelevant. We’re always being looked at, everybody. Maybe I’ve just grown more sensitive to that over time; maybe I’m underselling the one who looks, then.

I haven’t “always known.” Somewhere along the way, I came to know. At some point, the source of light shifted, the prism cast its colors differently, and I loved the hues emerging.

Time moves that way—erratically, tenderly—and so it will continue to move. Like a prime number, it remains, untouched by its own passing.

In the final weeks before she moved out, I began reflecting on what our neighborliness had meant to me. I was grateful that it had been her who lived across from me, someone who didn’t seem to judge. Despite the tension the glass between us carried, I had still felt at home, held, safe. I thought of how many other people could have lived there instead of her, and how different my life might have been. How I might have never felt the space I’d been allowed to feel with her.

Moving boxes appeared. Faded patches on the wall where the clippings had once hung. My body was already bracing itself for the swell of a new wind. A new neighbor, a new angle and intensity of gaze, a new charge hanging like mist between our windows. Above all, I felt sorrow at her leaving. To me, she had been a quiet friend, an ally, even though we had never exchanged a single word. At a unique point in time and space, something ephemeral had blossomed between us. Deep down, I knew it would never happen again.

At the time, I thought about writing her a letter and slipping it through her mailbox before she left for good. But I imagined the envelope landing on her doormat, how intense that must be, receiving such a story from someone you’d never spoken to. Still, I wanted to be able to give back something, anything, as a way of thanking her. But in the end, I never did. One day, the apartment across the way was empty, the letter unwritten.

I still hope this text might one day reach her, that someone might recognize her in these words, in the color I’ve tried to give her. Maybe one day she’ll read it and come to understand what she has meant to me.

The strange thing is, I saw her again afterwards. Once at the cinema, once at IKEA. I was waiting for my sister by the restaurant when she suddenly appeared with her boyfriend. For a slow-motion moment, we exchanged looks under the beehive buzz of the crowds. I wasn’t sure if she recognized me. I was getting used to running into friends and seeming a stranger to them. But I didn’t have time to overthink; fractions of a second later, we became masked again by the masses surrounding us. The city turned out to be smaller than I’d thought, or maybe our worlds overlapped more than I’d expected. But even with complete overlap, one can still choose to hold their tongue.

Later that night, a memory crept in. I was eight years old, standing next to my dad in our garden, gazing eagerly at the sky. A silly pair of glasses shielded my eyes from the darkening sun as night spread its wings at noon. Summer fell silent, and we were slowly engulfed in shadow.

As I cycled out of the parking lot, a similar stillness lingered. As if the birds had stopped singing, a silence sudden and absolute. Yet it seemed to lag behind, somehow; the eclipse had already passed. She didn’t live there anymore.

A blackbird looked up from a patch of grass. Beady-eyed, it watched the passing shadow.