
“My clock’s ticking,” Patricia had said after roughly one year of being with her, “but I’m not ready to take care of a child yet. I first need to overcome some personal battles.” And the clock kept ticking.
Then, not more than a week ago, about four years into our relationship, she said, “My biological clock struck the final hour, and it’s time because soon there might be no time at all.” And the time stopped.
I understood. Biology. Modern medicine was becoming more and more advanced; you’d read about women having firstborns in their sixties. But you didn’t want to play cat and mouse with these things, not with a woman’s biological clock. Patricia really wanted to be a mother, and I wasn’t going to stand in her way, as strange as it sounds, because not standing in her way meant having to reciprocate accordingly, to stop pulling out, that is.
The question was never formulated in terms of my readiness. I knew this was always more about her than about me, even if we’re talking about something—a baby, in this case—that requires two people to make. But I get it, men are less pressed about their biological clock.
I didn’t want to make it about myself, my insecurities, my doubts, my fears, and so on. I was always averse to the spotlight. “If you think it’s time, then it’s time,” I said not more than a week ago. We kissed and hugged and snuggled after that. In the way she touched me, I felt that it meant the world to her. I was happy I could make her feel that way.
In fact, I came to know that I have doubts about having a baby and everything it entailed only after I agreed to have a baby with her. It happened a day or two after our agreement. Not the best time, I thought to myself, to overthink a decision after you’ve already agreed on something.
But I didn’t feel like turning back, retracting my stance after I gave my blessing, as it were. I wasn’t about to open up and make Patricia doubt and feel insecure, or worse, shatter her hopes. Not now. That was the last thing she needed, after she had decided to have a baby with me. So I was left to deal with my insecurities alone and hope they’d magically evaporate, as they frequently did when push came to shove.
Not in this case, I realized when we were having sex for the first time after making our decision.
***
Patricia lay on the couch, watching a reality show on the screen while I cooked dinner. The pan sizzled as the voices from the TV blurred into the kitchen. I looked at her lithe body, covered in pajamas and woolen socks, the desk lamp on the windowsill softening her profile, her skin smooth as sanded wood, her shaded jawline both sharp and polished. I was stirred. I approached from behind and kissed her on the cheek, spatula in hand, cooking apron around my waist. Without turning from the screen, she wrapped her fingers around my wrist—the one still holding the spatula—and squeezed it affectionately. I wanted her that night.
We ate and talked. I cooked and she rinsed the dishes and put them in the dishwasher. When I returned from walking Pepe around the block, Patricia was already reading in bed. I washed myself, brushed my teeth and joined her under the blanket. My hands were still cold from being outside with Pepe, who had taken his precious time marking every lamppost in the neighborhood.
I warmed my hands between my thighs, not wanting to startle her with an icy touch. Then I slithered toward her and rested my hand on her sculpted waist. Sensing my body language, Patricia set aside Knausgård’s My Struggle with elegant precision, placing it face-up on the bedside table without a sound. I always adored her graceful movements. She slipped under the blankets and placed her hand on my waist, mirroring my touch. We looked at each other for a long, intense moment before we kissed.
But on the brink of the irreversible change we both explicitly agreed upon, when I was about to come inside her, I faltered. Anticipating the orgasm, a moment before I was about to ejaculate, when that signaled that I should be as deep in her as I could be, I faltered. I was not as physically deep as I could have been. I was barely inside, in fact. I hesitated—my fears, doubts and insecurities towed me away at the exact moment when I had to be fully committed. In that instant, something inside me recoiled from life.
I couldn’t bring myself to tell her of my failure.
We both fell on our backs and I consoled myself, making up excuses that not everyone was able to conceive right away, and that it was normal; some people tried for decades until they managed, but I’m not sure I truly believed it.
I knew it wasn’t about her or her body. It was about me failing to keep my side of the bargain—about me failing to do the simplest thing you could ask of a man—to finish in her as physically deep as possible, at the spot where the penis reaches the recess at the back of the cervix, as Patricia and I read when we googled best sex poses for getting pregnant. Instead, I ejaculated only with my tip in, only then did I thrust my hips—after the fact—to avoid suspicion, out of fear of being caught failing to keep my side of the bargain. I made it appear as if responsibility was with Patricia’s body to take care of the rest.
The discussion always revolved around whether Patricia could become pregnant at all, given her condition, her polycystic ovaries. The pressure was all on her side; nobody doubted my contribution or my ability to perform, which, of course, only made things worse. Without any pressure, I could feign my contribution—my performative act—and deem it successful and displace the responsibility on Patricia’s ovaries and her condition. In other words, I could deceive her without any suspicion falling on me. Indeed, I did just that; I deceived her just two days after we agreed to have a baby together.
Patricia turned to me and said, her voice gliding, indolent and carnally satisfied, “I’m so happy we’re doing this.”
Her words cut right through me. Only the dimness of our bedroom and the fact that I was lying on my back saved me from being caught right then and there—I was paralyzed with terror. Cold sweat slicked my skin like condensation on a window. It took time before I summoned the courage to answer. “Me too,” I said with as much spark as a week-old Coca-Cola.
Patricia didn’t seem to notice. She moved closer and hugged me with great—almost motherly—intensity. Then she wrapped her legs around me and placed her head on my chest. “I love you,” she said.
“I love you too,” I replied before sinking into silence. She gave me a goodnight kiss and turned her back to me—that’s how we always fell asleep, turned away from each other. It took me a long time to drift off, but even then, I slept lightly, tentatively.
Having slept poorly that night, I picked a small argument in the morning—about her forgetting to rinse the pan last night, or something equally trivial. I wasn’t one to argue over such small things, and I realized it almost immediately. I told myself I couldn’t start an argument over something so trivial, not after deceiving her only two days after we decided to have a baby. I apologized, blaming my poor night’s sleep for my unbecoming antics.
“How come you’ve slept poorly?” Patricia said, applying anti-aging cream under her eyelids. “Usually it’s me having nightmares.”
“I don’t know,” I answered, stroking Pepe’s back on my lap, my voice meek.
From that day on, cloudy, somber thoughts wove through my mind. Why had I deceived Patricia when I was supposed to commit? How could I so easily deceive the person I loved more than anyone? Why did I nearly pull out when I was supposed to finish inside her, as deep as I could? What had caused me to pull away at the very last moment, when I had to do the simplest thing expected of me? Why did I commit with words but not with actions?
I was a coward, a man who talked but didn’t walk the walk. And I was not only a coward, but also a deceptive schmuck, unable to admit to Patricia that I was, at the core, nothing but that.
I crumbled when she needed me to be rock solid, to be a man. For four years, I had hardly ever disappointed her. She saw me as a man she could rely on, a solid foundation to build a mutual future on. But now, when it mattered most, I toppled over and spoiled everything with my performative act.
Worse still, only I knew the truth. In Patricia’s eyes, I was more solid and unwavering than I had ever been. In her world, my stock was at an all-time high. But rot spreads from inside out. There was no way back, no undo button for what I had done.
In sheer despair, I confided in Paul, my best friend. That wasn’t something I normally did, I never openly pleaded for assistance in such detail. Usually, just like in my relationship, I was the one to offer support, the sturdy shoulder providing temporary relief from life’s tussles.
Even with my best friend, even when I was scraping the bottom of the barrel for hope, I couldn’t bring myself to tell the whole truth. Out of shame, terrible shame, I downplayed what I had done, as if it were some fluke.
Paul, naturally, urged me to right the wrong as soon as Patricia and I were going to have sex again, to redeem myself for this lapse. When we split ways, I realized I was still a deceptive and cowardly schmuck who couldn’t bear to disclose the real situation even to his best friend. In other words, out of my terrible shame, I had deceived my best friend too.
I was a fraud, more concerned with how others saw me than the state of my own soul. Something in me, despite the unbearable despair eating me inside, still chose to save face by not spilling the beans, as it were.
And then that word struck me like a gong’s peal—deliciously in its repetition, dear in its sound. Pride, pride, pride, it echoed through me. It felt like a cure to finally find the name for my performative act, the cause of my deceptive behavior. At last, my situation latched onto something, some barbed wire jutting from the road to despair.
My frenzy was short-lived. What was I to do with this discovery, this pride, the root of my deceptions? I still was a cowardly, deceitful and prideful schmuck who had failed to keep his side of the bargain, failed to do the simplest thing expected of a man after agreeing to have a baby with a person he loved more than anyone on this planet.
How could she possibly want to have a baby with someone who had deceived her, who, out of cowardice and pride, had feigned his role through a performative act, pretending to do what he had to do? Someone who even said I love you too right after his devious trick, how could she possibly still want a child with such a man?
I needed to tell her. It was a question of pride. I had to expose my deceptions and cowardice so she would know exactly who she was dealing with—a schmuck of unrivaled proportions. She had to see the truth before it was too late, before I blighted her with more of my lies and performative acts.
What I had done was unforgivable. After four years together, after convincing her I was someone she could build a future with, someone she could have a child with, I deceived her, and I had done it when it mattered most.
“In therapy you make yourself naked. You learn to see yourself naked and to reveal yourself to loved ones when you need help,” Patricia had once said when we discussed her weekly therapy session, as we always did.
Only now did I understand what she meant. Only now was I to strip myself bare before her for the first time in four years. Only now was I ready to reveal my freshly discovered rotten insides, only to lose her.
But, out of pride, I had to do it. I had to show her my deception, my cowardly disposition to falter when push came to shove, when it mattered most. And I would lose her for it—how could she possibly stay? How could she continue this relationship, let alone have a baby with a man like me, a man who had failed her at the moment it mattered most?
She knew something was up. “You’re an open book,” she said. “There’s no point hiding what you feel, I can read your face.”
Yes, I thought, you can tell something is wrong, but you can’t read the contents of my despair, even if I were an open book. Watching her brush her hair in the bathroom leaning against the door jamb, I thought: You don’t know that I’m a deceptive and cowardly schmuck who, out of pride, feigned his performative act, who tricked you in the most devious way possible at the very moment when intimacy and truth mattered most.
When Patricia asked if I was okay, I replied, “Yes, I’m fine. There’s nothing wrong with me.”
“You sure?” she insisted.
“Yes, just feeling a bit gloomy, that’s all. Let’s leave it there for now,” I said.
But by the third or fourth time, she sat me down on the sofa and said, “I can see you suffering and I can’t stand it, seeing you like this, dragging your feet, hardly smiling. What is it?” She leaned in. “You won’t get away now.”
This was it, now or never, the hour of reckoning had come. She would finally learn the truth and it would be the end to our four years together. Her facial features suddenly tightened, her back tensed when she saw I was about to blurt out my confession, when she realized that something really was up, and most likely supposed it had to do with her, us.
“I’m a deceptive and cowardly schmuck, Patricia. I faltered and deceived you when it mattered most,” I said stroking Pepe’s soft fur. He had jumped on the sofa just before my confession and settled on my thigh.
“I failed to do the simplest thing one could ask of a man; I failed to finish as deeply as possible inside you when we had sex for the first time after agreeing to have a baby together. Only two days after I gave you my word, I betrayed it. Something in me, my doubts, fears, and insecurities, gnawed at me, towing me away from your body right at the moment when I was supposed to finish in you.”
Pepe was about to doze off out of pleasure.
“I faltered and then deceived you because I put up my performative act, acting as if I did what I was supposed to, given our agreement to have a baby together. I stayed mum, not telling you, acting as if I did the simplest thing one could ask of a man, pushing the responsibility on your shoulders, your condition, your polycystic ovaries, leaving you clueless and deceived when it mattered most.”
Patricia listened quietly.
“And, I’m sure,” I continued, still stroking Pepe’s back, “that you now understand who you’re dealing with. The man you planned to build a future with, a family with, is a rotten, deceptive and cowardly schmuck. Despite loving you with my heart and soul, to the moon and back, I deceived you when it mattered most, at the most intimate and vulnerable moment imaginable.
“There goes our four years into the wastebasket the moment your biological clock struck, just as you said a week ago. And I, quite unforgivably, failed to keep my side of the bargain. I’m sorry. I’m really sorry, Patricia.”
It came out of me like a soughing melody—rehearsed endlessly in my head, now recited out loud for Patricia.
When I finished, I broke down. From my abdomen to my throat, my body twitched and pulsated; emotion overtook me as searing tears streamed down my cheeks, waking Pepe. He looked at me with a worried and puzzled look.
I wailed like a child, unable to stop myself. I couldn’t bear to look, even glance, in the direction of Patricia.
Then I felt Patricia’s warm silhouette wrap around my convulsing body, leaving no room for Pepe. Squeezed between us, he wiggled his way to safety.
Patricia stroked my head, trying to soothe me, to calm me down. But I bleated on. I couldn’t stop. The cathartic energy had no bounds, it seemed. I could even hear her gentle attempt to appease me, whispering, “shhhh, shhhh.”
Here she was, baby in her lap, except in the shape of a grown man much bigger than her, I thought. Gradually, I managed to get a grip on myself. My excruciating convulsions receded. My tears gave way to sobbing, to hiccupy breath.
“It’s normal,” Patricia said, stroking my head. “It’s normal to doubt yourself sometimes. It’s normal to falter. I was the one who pushed for a baby.”
She cupped my head in her hands and turned me toward her. “But you have to talk to me,” she said, looking into my eyes. “You can’t just say yes and carry a knot of doubt and fear inside you.” I nodded.
She wiped a tear from my cheek with her thumb. “And besides,” she added after a long pause, “I knew you pulled out.”




